Who: Victor Wooten featuring Prasanna, Bangalore Amrit, Dr. Karthick
Where: Shanmukhanada Hall, Sion, Mumbai
When: 08 April 2010
There are certain times when your whole foundation is shaken, your entire understanding of the world turns on its head and you mock yourself asking where you were all these years.
You know, like the first time you went trekking outdoors, read a Wodehouse or, more recently, attended the Victor Wooten concert.
Equally stunning were the other musicians on stage - Carnatic guitar virtuouso Prasanna, and percussionists Bangalore Amrit on the Khanjira and Dr. Karthick on Ghatam. Granted, these aren’t ‘sexy’ or ‘methcul’ instruments. Unlikely to have you screaming your smoked lungs out and yell ‘Oh fuck yeaaaaah!’. But when two sandalwood-paste adorned, mundu-wearing traditional Indian percussionists leaves a crowd full of the who’s who of Indian Indie open mouthed, giving a standing ovation, and asking for more, you know you’re seeing something special.
But woah, woah, woah, I can hear you say, why aren’t you talking about the man of the day? Quite right. So let’s rewind.
Now I’m ashamed to admit I actually hadn’t heard of Wooten before a friend told me. Of course, our generation’s quick fix solution.
(Wikipedia + YouTube + official site) took care of that. For those who don’t know, Victor is one of the world’s most respected bass players, gaining popularity with the jazz fusion band Béla Fleck and the Flecktones.
I came in (to the quite nice and spacious Shanmukhananda Hall) when he was still answering questions from the crowd (I hear from reliable sources that the workshop was quite kickass) and just loved his sense of humour (Why’d you wanna play power chords on the bass? You’re gonna get a lot of guitarists pissed off, man!) and his appreciation of music. Sample this (paraphrased):
So now you’ve asked me a lot of questions about technique, slapping, tapping, harmonics, and all that. Lemme ask you something now. Define music, in one word.
(audience: Joy, happiness, love, emotion, expression…)
Yeah. Everywhere in the world I go, I ask this question, and get the same answers everywhere. Y’notice, not one of you said music was about technique, slapping, tapping…
The humility of the man, his ‘oneness’ with music, his calling his bass guitar ‘just a piece of wood, man’ just endeared him to the audience used to seeing inflated egos and showmen on stage. Refreshing.
Tanmay from everyone’s favourite jam band, Something Relevant introduced the complete ensemble and those who’ve heard Prasanna’s work knew they were in for a treat with this combination, almost a supergroup. His effortless rock-influenced Carnatic was a treat to listen to. He has an understated, quiet, style and a poker-faced sense of humour (“this track will be released in 2024… The recording was done last week but it will be out in 2024, if I’m right”). However, at times the solos were needlessly elongated (something I’ve always felt, ever since listening to Electric Ganeshaland - PS, check out who wrote the liner notes on this album. Heh!). His jugalbandhi with Wooten and then Karthick were stunning. Two standouts: Wooten playing Carnatic scale on the bass. Prasanna using a flange effect on his guitar, and Karthick using feedback from the hollow of his Ghatam to match him. Genius.
Being from a South Indian family, I’ve seen Ghatams before. But never a Khanjira. The range of sounds Amrit was able to get out of it was something else. While the front end provided the normal thwack, the edges provided a more liquidy feel. People who were at the concert will remember the li’l Pink Panther tune he played.
All this while, Wooten admirably ‘grooved’ with this foreign music. This is no surprise, really, given that he’s played genres from rock to jazz to fusion to world. Post the break, Wooten opened the show with a stunning 20-minute exhibition in which he also showed the audience how he uses his processor. It was the legend at his very best.
The show was not about the individual songs, really, it was about the sheer brilliance of four masters on stage. I’d stick my neck out and call it a sort of Carnatic Dream Theater. At the end of it all, we were left gasping. Most of us had never seen anything remotely like this before. It opened our minds up a little more.















Comments
9 comments. Add your own comment below.
Tucson Bass Player
Apr 17th, 2010 at 1:06 pm | #
I would love to see some videos of this mini tour. Just a piece of wood. ;-]
Sinister Minister
Apr 17th, 2010 at 3:46 pm | #
‘Carnatic Dream Theater’ it’s an insult to equate Victor Wooten with Dream Theater.
Suprateek
Apr 18th, 2010 at 1:56 am | #
Wow. was I actually at this concert?
I’m feeling lazy, so I’m just gonna enumerate what all wasn’t “quite cricket” about this hit-and-miss affair.
The Good:
1) Victor Wooten. Of course. The legendary bassist kept it real throughout with some jaw-dropping displays of slapping, layering and pure expression
2) Talent all round. Prasanna is a great guitar player with a mindblowing vocabulary. Amit and Dr Karthick were incredible and Wooten is Wooten.
The Bad:
1) Prasanna’s showboating and wannabe rock star antics. Seriously, it was almost embarrassing to watch. Jumping up and down, headbanging, adding the ‘Smoke on the water’, ‘Tom Sawyer’ etc riff to his composition. Sorry, did not work and was unnecessary. Seriously, why does he even bother — He’s too good a guitarist to resort to all this!
2) Overlong soloing, by everyone. Jugalbandis didn’t always work out — there was one which was pretty half-baked — and although Amrit and Dr Karthick were great, they’re no Vikku and Selvaganesh. Their solos could and shouldve ended earlier than they did.
The Ugly:
When you advertise a gig saying Victor Wooten live in MUmbai featuring Prasanna, I *guess* that means it shouldn’t be Prasanna with Amrit and Dr Karthick and, oh yeah, Victor Wooten providing able support on bass and playing a short crowd-pleasing solo set.
There were several times when Wooten was just left playing simple basslines while the other instrumentalists competed for attention. It was almost farcical at times. I had friends who came from Pune, Bangalore and Nashik who had come for the show, and I don’t see how it could’ve been worth their while (Hint: It wasnt).
While the show wasn’t terrible (since the abundance of talent on stage was crazy), it was a bit of a dissappointment for a lot of people in the audience.
It’s a well-written article, Deepak, but your inexperience shows in this piece esp when it comes to fusion bands and music.
I’m not trying to be mean or condescending… just giving my opinions and echoing whatever I heard some friends say.
Hudstin
Apr 18th, 2010 at 7:16 am | #
@Suprateek
I agree with what you had to say here 100 % , this is what exactly happened at the Chennai leg of the tour , People paid money and came with anticipation to watch Victor Wooten , and all they got was prassanna jumping around and not shutting up when needed , stealing the spotlight , even ended up ruining victors solo with his noisy guitar wankery.
Chuck
Apr 18th, 2010 at 9:20 am | #
Suprateek: Thanks. You’re right, I’m pretty inexperienced when it comes to fusion concerts and I’m sorry that reflected on the review. Hopefully readers of this article will get a better picture when reading your two bits as well :-)
Hopefully I’ll go to see more fusion shows and see what a real fusion show is like.
Chuck
Apr 18th, 2010 at 9:22 am | #
Heck man, I don’t mind the criticism. I hadn’t heard much of Wooten before this concert only :P
Again, thank you for the comments!
Suprateek
Apr 18th, 2010 at 2:51 pm | #
@Hudstin: Thanks. Oh YEAH, he just didn’t shut up!
@Chuck: Good on you for being a sport, man. I wrote that comment at 2 am or thereabouts, and now I realise I said quite a bit more than I meant to. :)
The worst thing about the gig was the ‘workshop’. What good is a one hour Q&A session with about 150-200 people in a huge-ass auditorium? How many questions are you actually going to end up asking, without being apprehensive of looking like a fool? Correct me if I’m wrong, but didn’t they charge Rs 1500 bucks for that?
I’m still not clear on why the workshop, which was supposed to be an all-day affair was suddenly changed to a one-hour thing. I heard something on the lines of ‘the hall wasn’t free’, and that’s just lame. I know people who found out about the change through Facebook just a day or two before the concert, after they’d already taken leave from work, commitments etc to attend the workshop. Ridiculous.
Also, at the risk of being awesomely verbose (I know, it’s too late to say that), I just want to say that PLEASE do not fuck audiences over by wrongful promotion. I deal with PR people all the time who do the same, and I tell them the same. The Wooten gig was a Big Fat Giant Plug for Prasanna, His Album and the Swarnabhoomi Academy of Music. Fine, theek hai — say THAT! Don’t attempt to draw audiences by saying Victor Wooten live in Mumbai. The guy wasn’t even given a mic for crying out loud.
Tanmay
May 2nd, 2010 at 9:40 pm | #
hey superteek!
the whole ‘tour’ was mismanaged. crazy shit.
anyways, victor loved india and wants to come back. (this time with the flecktones…fingers crossed)
Chuck
May 6th, 2010 at 4:46 pm | #
Now THAT would be something very relevant :]